Record and compare search observations

Method for recording search observations: scope, response, citation, source and limits.

Document monitoring desk with a notebook, clock and resources to consult.

AI-generated illustration

READING / ANNOTATED CASE

Four checks, four outcomes kept separate

Two fictional services answer the same questions about an imaginary museum. Each row checks one claim against one source; it does not rate the whole service. Keep mode, language and run comparable.

Fictional example · no observation of a service or client.

On small screens, scroll the table horizontally.

Four checks, four outcomes kept separate
Case · serviceClaim checkedReading outcome
C01 · AThe museum opens on Sundays.Supported: the passage describes Sunday hours.
C01 · BThe museum opens on Sundays.Unchecked: link recorded, passage not yet read.
C02 · AAdmission is free for everyone.Contradicted: the source distinguishes a general fee and exemptions.
C02 · BAdmission is free for everyone.Unavailable: the source could not be read at the time.
Can this be called 25% reliability?

No. One favourable check out of four does not describe overall reliability: one source remains unread and another unavailable. Report all four statuses and counts. Even one favourable check among two read passages, or 50%, describes only this tiny selection.

What if the link becomes available tomorrow?

Add a dated reading and its outcome, linked to the original observation. Do not silently replace ‘unavailable’: it records the conditions of the initial check.

Build an interpretable comparison

Identify case and series

A case identifies the tested question; a series identifies a dated repetition. Reuse identifiers across services for the same case.

Separate claims

Give each claim an identifier. For several sources, add several checks. Counts concern these pairs, not a quality ranking.

Retain conditions

Service, mode or model, language and time with zone accompany the check. A blank mode remains unknown.

Classify after reading

Open the source passage before declaring support or contradiction. A cited reference without a checked passage remains unchecked.

Distinct URLs and declared origin groups do not prove independence. A common case only means case, series and language identifiers match across entered services; modes, access and dates still need examination.