In-depth practical guides

Check publication corrections and retractions

Before citing a study, identify its editorial status, update notice and the passage affected by a correction or retraction.

Updated :

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

Does the cited version still support the claim?

An accessible and widely indexed article may have changed after publication. Distinguish the work, its version and the notice changing its status. A correction can concern one table; a retraction requires reviewing the document’s use. Preserve the exact qualification and update dependent content.

  1. Identify the work

    Retain DOI, title, authors, journal, year and used version. Separate preprint from publication. Keep the publisher URL and bibliographic record.

  2. Open the publisher page

    Look for linked corrections, expressions of concern, retractions or republication. Read the entire notice instead of a search-result label.

  3. Use discovery services

    Check Crossmark where offered and update links in indexes. Crossmark facilitates discovery but is not a guarantee. Finding no notice does not prove none exists.

  4. Compare notice and cited text

    Identify affected figure, table, method, author or conclusion. Retain article and notice DOIs separately. Do not turn a local correction into blanket invalidation or a retraction into a minor typo.

  5. Review dependent content

    Find pages, charts and comparisons using the passage. Reassess the claim, replace evidence where needed and publish a dated correction. Read alternative studies within their own scope.

  6. Schedule rechecking

    Keep the verification date and corpus owner. Reopen important references before republication or decisive use.

Reading workshop

The same identifier does not preserve the same evidence

Article DEMO-P and notice DEMO-C are invented. No real DOI is assigned to these teaching objects.

Fictional data and records for learning: none of these results comes from a live service query.

A corrected unit changes the claim to reuse

An old table copy refers to 120 people. A notice visible on the article page corrects the unit: 120 visits, not a count of distinct people. In this scenario the article DOI stays unchanged.

  1. Identify the cited copy

    Fictional record
    Old DEMO-P PDF
    Reading
    The summary depends on this table version
    Action
    Retain the initial version and passage.
  2. Open the linked notice

    Fictional record
    DEMO-C: table unit corrected
    Reading
    The number remains 120 but now counts visits
    Action
    Read the whole notice and its relation to the article.
  3. Reassess the claim

    Fictional record
    “120 distinct people”
    Reading
    The corrected table no longer supports this wording
    Action
    Use visits or seek a record about people.
  4. Track dependencies

    Fictional record
    Summary, chart and translations
    Reading
    Uses of the passage need reassessment
    Action
    Mark each reviewed or pending output.

Which decision actually follows the correction?

Open each proposition to compare its diagnosis. More checks may still be needed.

Keep the sentence because the DOI is unchanged

No. The identifier does not replace reading the notice and the version used.

Declare every article result invalid

No. This notice concerns a specific unit. Examine scope before extending the conclusion.

Correct the dependent claim and retain version history

Yes. A visit count does not give a distinct-person count. Review content that repeated this equivalence.

Fictional status record

Article: DEMO-P; original DOI unchanged in the scenario
Linked notice: DEMO-C, unit correction
Old reading: 120 people
Corrected reading: 120 visits
Distinct people: not established by this table
Follow-up: review summary, chart and languages

The DEMO labels identify separate records, not registered DOIs. The filled log lists work to do, not translations already approved.

Documentation of the rules, separate from fictional examples

Compare other situations and exercises

Corrected table

Recalculate with the corrected values and notes. Update chart, summary and language versions if the reported result changes.

Retracted article presented as established evidence

Suspend that qualification, read the notice and find appropriate evidence. Historical discussion can still reference the article with explicit status.

Old downloaded PDF

Return to the DOI and current publisher page. A local file may not reflect later editorial events.

Worked exercise

A correction changes the result, not every citation

Fictional example: the values and documents teach the method and do not describe a real organisation.

The correction notice replaces the denominator. The secondary record has not yet incorporated the change.

If the table exceeds the screen, scroll horizontally; arrow keys work when the region is focused.

Starting information
SourceCasesDenominatorQuoted rate
Initial version124030 %
Correction notice1260Not stated
Secondary recordNot statedNot stated30 %

Your checks

  1. Link the notice to article and version.
  2. Recalculate the corrected result.
  3. Find dependent summaries and charts.
Read the answer

Answer and decision

12/60 = 20%. The secondary profile retains an outdated value for this calculation. Correct the rate and explain the change, citing the notice. Crossmark can reveal updates; an absent button does not establish that an item was never corrected.

If the case changes

If the correction only fixes a typo unrelated to this calculation, do not invent a changed result.

Record to retain

Keep identifier, notice, versions, corrected cell and affected citations.

Documentation reference : Crossref — Crossmark · Consulted on

Record to retain

  • Work DOI, version and publisher URL.
  • Notice type, date, URL and identifier.
  • Affected passage, claim impact and dependent content.
  • Editorial decision, published correction, owner and review date.

Official references

Related source profiles

Related protocols

Checks before reaching a conclusion

  • Are article and update notice identified separately?
  • Is impact assessed on the actual cited passage?
  • Do summaries, data and translations preserve the status?

Frequently asked questions

Does a correction invalidate the entire study?

Not automatically. Read its scope and reassess the passage used.

Does missing Crossmark indicate retraction?

No. Its absence determines neither validity nor the absence of an editorial event.

Can a retracted paper be cited?

For documenting retraction or publication history, give the status and notice. Avoid treating its findings as established evidence without further examination.

Does a correction invalidate the entire publication?

Its scope must be examined in the opinion and paragraphs concerned. The effect on the precise use of the document should be verified rather than a general invalidation of the only change of status.

DEEPER READING / PRACTICE

Check the version and associated reviews

A publication is quoted without control of its documentary status. The verification searches for the corrections, new versions and reviews available in the publication sources.

Updated on .

Priority checks

Release the ID, version, date and page of the publisher or deposit. Examine the related documents and keep the opinions actually found on the date of the check.

Interpretation pitfalls

The absence of a recovered opinion does not constitute a general guarantee on the content. Correction does not always mean that all conclusions are invalid.

Working record to retain

The report combines publication, consulted version, opinion, known scope and date. The summary explains the effect of the change on the passage used.