Scientific paper and reading magnifier. Illustrative scene.

GUIDE / RESEARCH

Verify a research reference and its version

A reference found in a search engine, AI answer or citation graph is a starting point. Check the exact document, its version and the passage that actually supports the claim.

AI-generated illustration

01 / GUIDE / RESEARCH

Identification is not validation

A DOI identifies a resource; ORCID distinguishes people and ROR organisations. These identifiers alone do not assess methods or findings. PubMed provides citations and abstracts with links to available text; HAL and repositories may hold different document types and versions. First write down the claim to check and the relevant period.

Guides
Complementary identifiers: DOI for a resource, ORCID for a person and ROR for an organisation. Relationships between them still need checking in documents.
Complementary identifiers: DOI for a resource, ORCID for a person and ROR for an organisation. Relationships between them still need checking in documents.

02 / GUIDE / RESEARCH

Six checks before reusing a reference

Check the consulted object without treating citation counts or open access as a truth label.

01

Document identity

Compare DOI or another identifier, title, authors and publisher. A title or suffix error may identify a different object.

Record to retain · Exact identifier and destination page
02

Version read

Distinguish preprint, accepted manuscript, published version, data and software. Record the file version, not just metadata.

Record to retain · Type, version, file and date
03

Author and affiliation

Check ORCID where available and compare affiliations with the document. Use ROR to resolve an ambiguous organisation.

Record to retain · Identifiers and relevant dated affiliation
04

Corrections and updates

Read linked notices and the publisher page; retain reported corrections, withdrawals and changes instead of leaving an old conclusion intact.

Record to retain · Notice, date and link
05

Passage and method

Open the text and locate the table, figure or paragraph. Record population, period and conditions required to understand the measure.

Record to retain · Precise locator and scope
06

Data and protocol

Follow declared repository or registration links; compare versions, files and planned methods with the reported result.

Record to retain · Repository, version, licence and deviations

03 / GUIDE / RESEARCH

Four steps for verification

Keep a short chain between question, text and conclusion.

  1. 01

    Recover the object

    Search DOI or exact title in Crossref, DataCite or the relevant index, then open the publisher or repository resource.

  2. 02

    Read the right version

    Record type, date and version; check update notices. If only an abstract is accessible, retain that limitation. If a Crossmark button is present, open it to check reported corrections and updates. Its presence is not a guarantee of quality.

  3. 03

    Test support for the claim

    Compare the passage with your question. Correlation, findings in a limited population and general conclusions are not interchangeable.

  4. 04

    Document without inflating evidence

    Keep identifier, URL, version, passage and access date. Do not count two records of one work as independent confirmations.

04 / GUIDE / RESEARCH

Four common situations

Methodological reading cases without invented findings or researchers.

01

An AI suggests a reference

Check existence and the precise passage. A real reference may be assigned to the wrong author or fail to support the generated sentence.

Read the dossier
02

One title appears in several databases

Compare identifiers and versions. PubMed, Europe PMC and a repository may describe one work with different files or metadata.

Read the dossier
03

Researchers share a name

Compare ORCID, publications, dates and affiliation; retain separate hypotheses until attributes support a match.

Read the dossier
04

A result cites a protocol

Open the relevant dated registration. Compare planned criteria, population and findings; absence in one register does not establish absence everywhere.

Read the dossier

A useful reference supports another check

Cite the precise page and version read. A portal title, search engine or access date does not replace the document date. Missing information stays missing; retain the uncertainty in your record.

Compose a public-source reference

06 / FAQ

Questions about publications and identifiers

Does a DOI guarantee peer review?

No. It may identify data, software or preprints, among other objects. Read the document type and editorial process.

Does PubMed always provide full text?

No. PubMed holds citations and abstracts; links may lead to PubMed Central or the publisher. Retain the version actually opened.

Does an ORCID affiliation establish current employment?

No. Check the field’s provenance and dates and the institution’s information; the public record may be partial.

Does no correction mean everything is reliable?

No. Checking updates complements reading methods and limits; it is not comprehensive scientific validation.

How should one cite only an abstract?

State that you consulted the abstract and restrict the claim to what it shows. Do not imply that you reviewed files or the complete method.

07 / Discuss a context

Keep a reference another reader can retrace

A useful record identifies the object, the version read and the conclusion’s scope.

DOCUMENTED REFERENCE

Person, organisation and publication: three identities

A bibliographic record links several objects. Check each relationship in the consulted material rather than transferring an identifier’s credibility to the entire result.

Person, organisation and publication: three identities
ReferenceValue or formWhat it identifies
ORCID16Person; the final check character may be X.
ROR9Research organisation; string beginning with 0.
DOI10.…/…Resource; prefix and suffix separated by a slash.

Implication for the record

Keep full ORCID and ROR URLs and the DOI of the version used. Matching identities does not establish current affiliation, peer review or a valid conclusion.

Primary documentation

Documentation consulted on .

DOCUMENTED REFERENCE

ISSN and ISSN-L: distinguish medium, serial and article

An ISSN identifies a continuing resource, not every article or issue. ISSN centres and national libraries distinguish medium versions. Before joining catalogues record the actual identifier type and catalogue links.

ISSN and ISSN-L: distinguish medium, serial and article
ReferenceValue or formWhat it identifies
ISSN8 · last = 0–9 / XSeven base digits plus a check character. Final X means ten in modulus-eleven arithmetic; do not remove it as OCR noise.
Example0317-8471Library of Congress example: weights 8 through 2 give 120; check digit 1 yields 0317-8471. The calculation alone does not name the publication.
Example X2434-561XThe cited NDL record links this ISSN to another medium version. Its valid X cannot survive a numeric-only column.
MediumPrint / onlinePrint and online versions have separate ISSNs. Arbitrarily treating one as every medium erases useful bibliographic distinctions.
ISSN-LLinking ISSNLinking ISSN groups different medium versions of the same continuing resource. It is not a third medium or an article DOI.
UnitContinuing resourceThe unit is the continuing resource. Article references also need title, author, date, volume, issue, pages or article number and any article identifier.

Implication for the record

The number does not encode discipline, country or research quality. Consult catalogue history for title changes; do not join by title alone. Correct format establishes neither indexing, peer review nor editorial reputation.

Are two ISSNs on a journal an error?

Not necessarily: they may distinguish print and online. Check media and ISSN-L before deduplication; title-only merging can conflate namesakes.

Primary documentation

Documentation consulted on .

DOCUMENTED REFERENCE

A resolving reference may have been corrected

A DOI that resolves identifies a document; it does not establish its editorial status. Before reusing a scientific conclusion, look for linked corrections, retractions and other updates.

DOI · ACrossmarkDOI · BB → update-to → A
A resolving reference may have been corrected
ReferenceValue or formWhat it identifies
CrossmarkstatusWhere available, open Crossmark and read the status and update links. The button alone does not certify research quality.
update-toDOI + typeIn an update notice’s metadata, this field links the notice to the affected work’s DOI and describes the change type. Also read the publisher’s notice.
DOIidentifierRetain both DOIs, the change type and date, and the affected passage. Revisit the text used to decide whether the claim needs correction.

Implication for the record

No update link is not evidence that no correction exists: coverage depends on deposits and publisher participation. A preprint and published article may have separate identifiers.

Primary documentation

Documentation consulted on .

DEEPER READING / PRACTICE

Find the publication behind a reference

A bibliography contains a plausible title, but the document found does not match exactly. The verification must bring the title, authors, identifier and version closer.

Updated on .

Priority checks

Search the document with several attributes, then compare the metadata and the useful passage. Check if the quotation indicates a version, correction or secondary document.

Interpretation pitfalls

A valid ID does not confirm that the text supports the statement. An accurate reference can however be used outside its scope.

Working record to retain

The file combines received reference, found document, correspondence and relevant passage. The bibliographic differences and background differences are described separately.

PRACTICAL CASE / WORKED EXAMPLE

A plausible title does not correspond to the document cited

This is an illustration of documentary reading. It does not constitute an assessment of an entity or a real file; it shows the verification necessary to bring a public presentation of the documents actually available closer.

Example context

A reference looks like a real publication, but the authors and the year differ. The found document addresses the subject without exactly supporting the proposal.

Suggested approach

Compare title, authors, identifier and version. Find the useful passage and then check the scope and conclusion. Separate bibliographic correction and background verification.

Conclusion and next step

Correct the reference or flag it as unresolved. Keep the claim only in a form supported by the document actually found.

Questions for deeper practice

Is a resolved DOI sufficient to validate a reference?

It allows to find an object, but the bibliographic correspondence and the passage used must still be controlled. The identificator does not prove that the document supports the proposal.

DETAILED WORKSHOP / APPLICATION

Monitoring bibliographic correspondence and support of the statement

  1. 01 / Prepare the necessary information

    Prepare received reference, affirmation and identifiers available. Identify the attributes needed to find the exact publication rather than a text of a neighboring subject.

  2. 02 / Carry out the approach

    Compare title, authors, date and version, and then examine the passage supporting the proposal. Distinguish reference error, non-findable document and non-context use from a correct publication.

  3. 03 / Examine an alternative situation

    If the document found is close but different, do not replace it silently. The new item must be examined for its own support to the affirmation.

  4. 04 / Decide on the next step

    The reference is validated for the use described when the identity of the document and relevance of the passage are verified. The methodological reserves remain linked to the conclusion.

  5. 05 / Hand over the verification records

    Transmit initial reference, correction and localization. The reader can check the piece and understand why the statement has been retained, modified or suspended.

ANNOTATED WORKING DOCUMENT / REVIEW GRID

A bibliographic and relevant correspondence list

The file retains the reference received, the document found and the pass used. It separates title or identification correction and verification of the proposal supported by the publication.

On a small screen, scroll the grid horizontally to read all three columns.

Example situations to assess
ObservationSupported interpretationNext step
Title, authors, identifier and passage agree.The reference corresponds to the piece and the use examined.Keep version, location and useful reservations.
The document is real but concerns another scope.The bibliographic accuracy does not validate the statement.Repeat the word or look for an appropriate piece.
The title is close but the other attributes are different.The publication found should not be replaced silently.Document the difference and continue the identification.

Reviewing the working document

The final verification verifies the document and support of the passage. A successful identification resolution is a useful step but does not demonstrate the complete correspondence or relevance of the quotation.

REPORTING / EXAMPLE WORDING

Presentation of results: Find the publication behind a reference

Point to clarify

A precise reference can be used for a proposal that the document does not support.

Before handing over

Distinguish the identification of the piece and the relevance of its use.

Example of a qualified conclusion

The publication corresponds to verified bibliographic attributes. The useful passage was examined separately to qualify its support for the affirmation.