Choose a source family

Sources for scientific reference verification

Separate work, author, organisation, repository, journal and trial to cite the right object and version.

Scientific reading room and microscope. Illustrative scene.

AI-generated illustration

Choose the right source

Start with the object’s identifier: DOI or record ID for a work, ORCID for a person, ROR for an organisation, NCT for a trial. Then connect document and editorial status. Inclusion in an index, repository or registry does not independently validate the result.

Compare result types

Crossref and DataCite describe identified objects; PubMed and Europe PMC index literature; HAL and Zenodo host deposits. For OSF, distinguish Projects, Registrations and Preprints: the announced transition concerns Projects. ORCID and ROR help resolve identities. Multiple records can repeat the same metadata.

Reading example

A preprint and published article have similar titles. Read the relationship and versions, compare the passage used and check corrections or retractions. Do not count two versions of one work as independent studies.

Choose by the object sought

Choose by the object sought
SourceResult unitTime reference to retain
OpenAlexBibliographic record and publication linksDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
Crossref Metadata SearchBibliographic record and publication linksDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
ORCIDPerson identifier and assertions in the profileAccess date and displayed update date; current state does not reconstruct all history.
Research Organization Registry · RORResearch organisation identifier and name variantsAccess date and displayed update date; current state does not reconstruct all history.
HALDeposit, file, version and resource metadataDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
PubMedBibliographic record and publication linksDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
Europe PMCBibliographic record and publication linksDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
DataCite CommonsBibliographic record and publication linksDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
ZenodoDeposit, file, version and resource metadataDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
Directory of Open Access Journals · DOAJJournal and editorial policy, not assessment of every articleAccess date and displayed update date; current state does not reconstruct all history.
ClinicalTrials.govRegistered trial, protocol and results available separatelyDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
OpenAIRE EXPLOREBibliographic record and publication linksDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
Open Science Framework · OSFDeposit, file, version and resource metadataDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.
WHO ICTRP — registre des essaisRegistered trial, protocol and results available separatelyDocument or deposit version, publication and modification dates.

Choose the check for your case

Each question links comparable sources to a record to retain and a method. Services have different scope; open their profiles before drawing conclusions.

Sources in this family · 14

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

INT

OpenAlex

Explore open metadata for scholarly works, authors, institutions and citation links.

Coverage and record matching vary; inclusion or citation counts do not validate scientific quality.

Do three locations establish three works?

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

INT

ORCID

Find a researcher identifier and the contributions or affiliations made public in their record.

Check each item’s provenance; visibility and completeness vary by record, and an identifier does not certify expertise.

Who asserted this affiliation?

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

INT

HAL

Find published or unpublished research outputs, metadata records and deposited files in a multidisciplinary open archive.

Distinguish metadata-only records, preprints and published versions; deposit alone is not scientific assessment.

Does a HAL record mean you read the text?

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

INT

PubMed

Find biomedical and life-sciences citations and abstracts, then follow full-text links where available.

PubMed is not a general full-text archive; indexing alone does not validate a finding or medical recommendation.

Is a record added today a new study?

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

INT

Europe PMC

Search life-sciences literature, preprints and links to full text, data and related resources.

Identify document type and version; records from different platforms may describe the same work.

Is readable full text freely reusable?

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

INT

Zenodo

Find deposited datasets, software, publications and other research objects with metadata and identifiers.

Retain the version and licence of the file used; public deposit does not guarantee reproducibility or content quality.

Should the concept or a specific version be cited?

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

INT

Open Science Framework · OSF

Consult OSF projects, preregistrations and preprints, identifying resource type and version. The announced Projects transition starts on 16 November 2026; see the documented schedule in the profile.

Distinguish a project file from a Registration. Announced preservation of content and identifiers establishes neither protocol adherence nor result quality.

Does the current project preserve the pre-analysis plan?

Practise with this source family

Entirely fictional example: the data train reasoning and do not describe a real situation.

Check a scholarly reference

Two records have similar titles. Their DOIs differ and one describes a correction to the article.

Solve the worked case

Recover the version actually cited

A 2023 manuscript and a 2024 edition share a title. The cited page exists only in the 2024 edition.

Solve the worked case

Distinguish researchers with the same name

Two records share initials and surname. They list different personal identifiers and affiliations.

Solve the worked case

Find the data behind a publication

The article points to dataset version 1. The current download supplies version 2 with changed files.

Solve the worked case
See all 36 routes and exercises

Choose a source family

Topic pages to select a service and understand what its result can establish.

DEEPER READING / PRACTICE

Combine complementary sources

A category includes close services, but their content can answer different questions. The useful combination covers the dimensions that the first source leaves open.

Updated on .

Priority checks

Compare territory, period, identifiers and document types. Look for a source that adds context or chronology, rather than another repetition of the same result.

Interpretation pitfalls

Two sources of the same category may have a common origin. Their complementarity must be demonstrated by the information they provide.

Working record to retain

The source map combines question, service, obtained information and remaining gap. It makes visible the role of each consultation in the reasoning.