In-depth practical guides

Assess the independence of multiple sources

Count original records rather than links: identify republication, shared data and distinct observations before drawing a conclusion.

Updated :

Consultation of scientific publications and bibliographic references.

AI-generated illustration

Do two websites really confirm a fact twice?

Domains, logos and formats do not establish independence. Several outlets can reuse a press release, and a registry can feed both a portal and an API. Evaluate one precise claim: documents may have independent commentary while relying on the same figure. The output is a map of origins with remaining uncertainties.

  1. Split the claim

    Separate identity, date, amount, attribution and consequence. Retain the supporting passage for each element. One page can be primary for a statement and secondary for an estimate.

  2. Trace the original record

    Follow links, references, document numbers and producer details. Distinguish author, distributor and index. Stop at an identified document, not a search engine.

  3. Compare documentary features

    Match identifiers, versions, figures, wording and files. Unusual agreement can suggest republication but does not alone prove copying. Seek explicit attribution.

  4. Classify relationships

    Distinguish the same record, the same collection, new analysis of shared data and a distinct observation. Mark undocumented lineage as unknown rather than inventing a connection.

  5. Seek a useful contradiction

    Try another collection method, event or producer. Differences may come from scope or time; compare definitions before selecting a version.

  6. State the conclusion

    Describe original records supporting each claim and what agreement establishes. Matching portals can check transcription without providing independent observations.

Situations and decisions

Typical situations for preparing a check. They do not describe completed assignments or actual observations.

One decision, two portals

CNIL also publishes decisions on Légifrance. Match number, date and text; an identical decision counts as one record with two access paths.

One work, multiple indexes

OpenAlex documents inputs from Crossref, DataCite and PubMed. Match DOI and version; another record may improve discovery without adding a scientific experiment.

Republished press release

Find the original statement. A reporter may contribute an investigation: attribute declared and independently checked facts separately.

A loop with an exit

Fictional example: D repeats E; E repeats D and A. Reaching A allows inspection of an upstream document, but does not support assertions exchanged by D and E without a matching passage in A. Separate what A establishes from the circular surplus and request support for the latter.

Independence depends on the question

Fictional example: two teams independently calculate a mean from the same file. Agreement may check the calculation; it does not confirm the collection of observations twice. For a collection error, seek another measurement; for a calculation error, retain the file, rules and both processing runs.

Worked exercise

Five links, two information chains

Fictional example: the values and documents teach the method and do not describe a real organisation.

The five publications cover the same subject. E’s stated collection still needs checking against the specific fact sought.

If the table exceeds the screen, scroll horizontally; arrow keys work when the region is focused.

Starting information
PublicationStated originRecord or role
AAInitial press release
BAReproduction without a new record
CAReproduction without a new record
DBSummary
EAnother stated collectionData table

Your checks

  1. Connect each publication to its origin.
  2. Identify what E actually adds.
  3. Separate link counts from corroboration of the specific fact.
Read the answer

Answer and decision

A, B, C and D form one chain originating in the statement. E is a second declared origin to examine. Five links are not five independent confirmations; E may cover a different scope and fail to confirm the claim.

If the case changes

If E ultimately uses A's data, revise the origin map. A different domain alone does not establish independence.

Record to retain

Keep the reuse graph, original evidence and passage supporting each fact.

Documentation reference : W3C — PROV Model Primer, derivation and revision · Consulted on

Record to retain

  • Atomic claim, excerpt and original record identifier.
  • Author, data producer, distributor and consulted index.
  • Documented relationship, supporting link, version and date.
  • Unknown origin, remaining contradiction and resolving check.

Official references

Related source profiles

Related protocols

Checks before reaching a conclusion

  • Does every confirmation identify an original record?
  • Are shared documents separated from new collection?
  • Are undocumented relationships still marked unknown?

Frequently asked questions

Are different news outlets independent?

Not necessarily for the claim. Check whether they share a press release, witness or dataset.

Is a translation another source?

It is another language version of the same original document. Check the translation separately.

Are two sources always needed?

A number alone is insufficient. Use records competent for the question and disclose a single origin’s limits.

Apply the method to specific cases

Proposed exercise: this protocol is not a performed service test.

DuckDuckGo · What do Search Assist references establish?

If Search Assist appears, open its sources and identify the passage and document author supporting one specific claim.

Keep the Search Assist setting, claim text and original documents. Group copies of the same document before counting confirmations.

Record observations

DOCUMENTED REFERENCE

Corroboration: distinguish documents from origins

Six pages citing one another may describe just one observation. For a specific claim, map reuse before counting confirmations. The examples and reading rules below are this site’s teaching method; PROV-O documents provenance relations without supplying an independence score.

Corroboration: distinguish documents from origins
ReferenceValue or formWhat it identifies
A: -AThe − sign marks a declared stopping point. Identify the document and justify that choice: it certifies neither direct observation nor an independent origin.
A: ??The ? sign explicitly preserves an unknown origin. That document and every document leading to it retain an unresolved chain.
B: A,CB → A · B → CLinks run from reuse to its source. A circular group may also reach a known origin; that exit does not remove the loop.

Trace how a claim is repeated

Work on one claim and specific document versions. An arrow from B to A means here that B repeats A for this claim. Enter only links you have identified; retain the supporting passages in your case file.

One line per document, A to L, up to 12 documents. A: - is a declared origin in this model; A: ? an unknown origin; B: A,C a reuse of A and C. Every referenced identifier needs its own line. Duplicate links are merged. The syntax is the same in every language.

Load a fictional example

No URL is visited and no result is stored. With JavaScript, calculation stays in the page; without JavaScript, this site processes the form.

Reading the declared model

Documents described
6
Declared origins
1
Documents with unresolved chains
0
Circular groups
0

Two declared origins do not establish independence. A missing link in the model does not establish an absence of dependency. These counts measure neither truth, reliability nor the number of independent pieces of evidence.

Reuse map: each card shows the documents directly reused
AReuses for this claim →Declared origin (−)
BReuses for this claim →A
CReuses for this claim →A
DReuses for this claim →B
EReuses for this claim →C
FReuses for this claim →D, E
Origins and obstacles reachable by tracing each chain
DocumentReachable declared originsUnknown origin (?)Circular groups
AA——
BA——
CA——
DA——
EA——
FA——

A circular group contains documents that lead back to each other. The table also flags documents leading into the group. An exit to a known origin does not remove the loop; the signal calls for checking, not a verdict of invalidity. An em dash means no item of that category was found in the model.

What the four cases show

One shared origin

Six documents lead to A. F cites two repetitions, D and E, but both paths return to A: more links add no declared origin.

Two separate chains

Six documents lead to A or D. The model counts two origins; authors, observations, methods and any unrecorded common source still need checking.

A partly unknown chain

C leads to A and to B, whose origin is unknown. D and E form a loop with an exit to A. Five documents have an unresolved chain even though a known origin can be reached.

Circular citation

A, B and C refer back to each other. None is declared as an origin: by itself, the loop supplies no external observation for the claim being examined.

Implication for the record

Calculation covers only the links entered for one claim. It does not detect hidden reuse, check passages or validate PROV graph conformance. Revisit the model when a version, attribution or the claim under examination changes.

Primary documentation

Documentation consulted on .

DEEPER READING / PRACTICE

Trace the origin of apparent agreement

Several articles tell the same fact and seem to confirm it. It is necessary to look at whether they have separate elements or reproduce a common publication.

Updated on .

Priority checks

Compare quotes, formulations, links and timeliness. Returning to the original documents and distinguishing autonomous collection, comment and recall of the same declaration.

Interpretation pitfalls

A large diffusion does not constitute a large number of confirmations. Different presentation texts may, however, depend on the same statement.

Working record to retain

The map of origin connects publications and common origins. The number of families of truly distinct sources is described separately from the total number of links.