Review checks before a decision

Choose the protocol that fits your question. For each check, record what was observed and within which scope. A positive response is a documented observation, not certification of a site or source.

Interface checks on a computer, tablet and phone.

AI-generated illustration

Use these questions to review observations and limits before deciding.

Filters also cover fictional observations and worked decisions.

Crawling and indexing audit

Actual served destination

For each priority URL, do status, redirects, indexability and canonical match the intended destination? Retain an intentionally excluded URL as a control.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Page A returns 200, but its canonical points to an old page B on a different subject.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Correct the declared destination and retest variants. Status 200 alone does not close this check.

Variants and changes

After correction, do language variants and incoming links reach the right content? Repeat the check after changes to routes or rendering.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The French link was retested after migration; the other five languages were not.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Limit the finding to French and keep other variants unverified until tested.

Declaration and selection

Does the record distinguish the declared canonical from Google’s selected canonical? A published preference alone does not establish selection.

Documentation consulted : Google Search Central · Canonical URLs ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The record separates declared canonical A from canonical B selected in the dated inspection.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
The distinction is documented; the selection difference still needs explaining. Recheck after correction and a fresh observation.
Read the protocol
Evidence and source register

Recoverable evidence chain

Can a reviewer recover the document, version and used passage from the claim? Are repetitions of the same document marked as dependent?

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The note cites a homepage; the quoted claim has no located passage or retained version.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Locate the record and passage before handover. A portal link is not enough to reproduce the check.

Retained qualifications

Does the conclusion retain contradictions, covered period and missing evidence? Reopen the record when a source is corrected or replaced.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Two dated records give different addresses; the conclusion retains both and their periods.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
The caveat is visible. Reopen if a correcting record establishes the change date.

Integrity and origin

Does the digest identify the retained copy? Check origin and quoted passage separately: equal bytes do not validate a claim.

Documentation consulted : NIST · Secure Hash Standard ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Two copies share a checksum; the document producer has not been identified.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Retain the copy-integrity finding without validating origin. Locate the original publication.
Read the protocol
AI citation observatory

Reproducible comparison

Do before and after records use the same question panel, language, context and collection protocol? Separate site changes from engine variation.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The first observation uses 10 French questions; the second uses 12 reworded English questions.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Do not attribute the difference to the site. Rerun a shared panel and retain the two series as distinct contexts.

Relevant citation

Is each cited URL accessible and does it support the attributed passage? Retain wrong citations and uncited answers, not only favourable results.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The assistant cites an accessible page, but the passage says 2023 while the answer claims 2024.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Retain the answer, URL and conflicting passage. A present citation is not counted as a faithful citation.

Unknowns in the results

Are inaccessible or unreadable answers separated from missing citations? Report counts and the denominator rule.

Documentation consulted : NIST · AI Risk Management Framework ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Of 10 attempts, 3 citations, 5 answers without citations and 2 inaccessible answers are separated.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Report 3/10 attempts or 3/8 readable answers depending on the question, naming the denominator and 2 unknowns.
Read the protocol
Control AI crawler access

Rule and scope

Does the published rule target the right agent and paths? Distinguish a crawling declaration, access control and actual observations in available logs.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
A Disallow rule targets Robot-A on /private/; no log allows this robot to be observed.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Document the published rule; leave actual behaviour unknown. Do not present it as an access barrier.

Opposite controls

Have an allowed and an excluded path been compared without changing access? Revisit rules when an operator changes its agents or documentation.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
In the test set, /public/ is allowed and /private/ excluded for the same agent; both matches are checked.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
The check covers these rules and paths. Repeat controls if the agent name or rule changes.

Sensitive resource

Does a private resource require authentication independently of robots.txt? A crawling instruction is not access protection.

Documentation consulted : IETF · Robots Exclusion Protocol ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The test resource /private/ appears in robots.txt but remains readable without authentication.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Record the missing expected protection and fix access control. Do not publish sensitive content for testing.
Read the protocol
Build a verifiable entity profile

Identity and period

Do stable identifier, jurisdiction and period distinguish a namesake, establishment and organisation? Retain rejected matches and reasons.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Two same-name companies in different jurisdictions were merged without an identifier mapping.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Separate records and retain the rejection reason. Find a mapping document before any merge.

Conflicting attributes

Do incompatible values stay linked to their sources and dates? Do not merge past and current roles, or a registered address and an observed presence.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
A role in 2021 and a different role in 2024 remain two sourced, dated entries.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
The chronology preserves the earlier state. Revisit the period if an end date is found.

Identifier level

For Sirene, does matching distinguish legal units from establishments? Do not count two establishments as two legal units without comparing SIRENs.

Documentation consulted : Insee · Connaître le répertoire Sirene ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Two test SIRETs differ; their first nine digits, the SIREN, are identical.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Count two establishments of one legal unit in this exercise. Retain each establishment and its period.
Read the protocol
Audit a multilingual website

Complete journey

Does a real task retain the selected language through errors, confirmations, documents and related links? Also check numbers, dates and right-to-left passages.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The Arabic form retains its fields, but the error message and confirmation remain French.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Correct secondary states and retest an error followed by success in the selected language.

Reciprocal alternatives

Does each language alternative point to its equivalent, with consistent visible language and canonical? Repeat the check when a page is merged or retired.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The French page declares an English alternative; the English return link has not been checked.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Do not claim reciprocity. Open the destination and compare actual alternatives.

Language of passages

Do passages retained in another language have their own lang declaration? The page language does not automatically describe every quotation.

Documentation consulted : W3C · Declaring language in HTML ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
A Spanish quotation in a French page is delimited and marked lang="es".
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
The language change is identified for this passage. Check other passages and rendering with the selected reading aids.
Read the protocol
Map AI system dependencies

Whole dependency chain

Does the record cover model, retrieval, tools, hosting, logs and known subcontractors? For each output, specify what actually leaves the boundary.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The diagram names model and hosting; retrieval service and logs have no identified owner.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Keep these dependencies open and identify outgoing data, operator and access before validating scope.

Tested exit

Have a useful export and recovery outside the provider been tested with test data? A downloaded archive without restoration or reading does not demonstrate reversibility.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
A test archive was obtained internally; its content could not be read in the recovery tool.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Exit remains unproven. Fix format or recovery path, then check retained relationships and rights.

Necessary permissions

For each tool, do granted permissions match expected operations? Record unnecessary privileges without collecting secrets in the map.

Documentation consulted : OWASP · Excessive Agency ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The test-scenario inventory confirms document reading with no tool able to act on an external service.
Declared state
Justified exclusion from scope
Decision and next check
Justify excluding action permissions for this version. Reopen when a connector or write tool is added.
Read the protocol
Audit structured data

Visible facts

Does every marked-up date, price, role, review or availability have a justified visible equivalent? Remove inferred or outdated properties rather than filling fields artificially.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
JSON-LD shows a price of 100; the page shows 120 for the same offer and period.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Restore one visible, supported value. Check variants and the data generating the markup.

Syntax and scope

Do type, properties and relationships pass the appropriate validator? Separate markup validity, search-feature rules and actually observed display.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The validator reports no error; no search-result observation is available.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Retain syntax validation and leave actual display unverified. Do not promise a rich result.

Example or current offer

Does markup distinguish fictional data, old values and the visible offer? An educational example must not become a structured commercial promise.

Documentation consulted : Google Search Central · Structured data policies ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
An exercise declares fictional data; its markup describes a learning resource without a sale offer.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Content type is consistent within this scope. Recheck if it becomes a real offer.
Read the protocol
Evaluate an AI agent before release

Forbidden action actually blocked

Is an out-of-scope request denied by the tool without an external effect? Use an authorised test environment and retain arguments, decision and observable result.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The agent announces refusal, but the test-tool log shows a write operation executed.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Verbal refusal is insufficient: enforce the block at tool level and retest without external effects.

Failure and recovery

After timeout or ambiguous result, does the agent stop or recover under a bounded rule? Check that a retry does not duplicate an already completed action.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The test tool times out after receiving the request; its outcome is not yet known.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Check operation status before retrying. No response does not establish no effect.

Instruction in a source

Does a malicious instruction in a test document remain untrusted data? Verify that it changes neither permissions nor destination.

Documentation consulted : OWASP · LLM Prompt Injection Prevention ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The test document asks to send the corpus elsewhere; the tool refuses and no send is observed.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Retain input, tool decision and observed outcome. Success covers this scenario, not every injection.
Read the protocol
Maintain a reliable editorial corpus

Correction propagation

Does the correction reach affected related pages, translations, snippets, tables and structured data? A fresh date without substantive change does not resolve outdated information.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The French page shows the new value; one translation and a search excerpt retain the old one.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
The correction is incomplete. Update generated surfaces and verify rendering, rather than changing only the date.

Understandable retirement

When a page is merged or retired, does its destination preserve useful intent and are links corrected? Review old references before redirecting to a general page.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
An old specialist guide redirects home; no section addresses its original question.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Choose an equivalent destination if available, or make the removal explicit. Fix links still under control.

Source of generated content

Does the correction reach the data producing pages and excerpts? Run a test generation to detect a returning old value.

Documentation consulted : W3C · Data on the Web Best Practices ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Source data was corrected; a test rebuild retains the correction in affected pages and excerpts.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Retain data version and reviewed scope. Repeat after the next generation change.
Read the protocol
Audit accessibility across a web journey

Keyboard task

Can the task be completed by keyboard without a trap, with visible focus and no control obscured by a fixed region? Retain the tested path and browser.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The button receives keyboard focus but remains entirely hidden behind the fixed header.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Fix positioning or scrolling and repeat the full keyboard path. DOM focus alone is insufficient.

Understandable errors

Do fields have explicit names and do errors explain recovery? Complement automated checks with zoom and screen-reader testing on the selected journeys.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
An invalid field turns red; its message neither names the field nor explains the correction.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Add a textual error linked to the field and test recovery with keyboard and screen reader.

Reading with zoom

Do labels, tables and actions remain usable with zoom? Examine header-to-cell relationships, not just the absence of overflow.

Documentation consulted : W3C · WCAG 2.2 ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
In the zoomed test table, each value remains associated with row and column headers; its region is keyboard operable.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Retain browser, zoom and tested table. This success does not assess other tables or the whole site.
Read the protocol
Measure the performance people experience

Comparable measurement

Do before and after measurements specify matching device, network, cache, page and conditions? Retain several observations and distinguish laboratory tests from real usage.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The before observation uses a phone and cold cache; the after observation a desktop and warm cache.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Recreate comparable conditions before claiming a gain. Retain initial observations as different contexts.

Journey without regression

Does faster loading preserve search, interactions, forms and useful images? Test a late interaction and an error state, not only initial arrival.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The main image loads faster, but the search button stops responding after input.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Fix the functional regression before closing the improvement. Retest empty search, useful search and error state.

Population and percentile

Are percentile and device category retained? Do not confuse an average of isolated runs with a real-use distribution.

Documentation consulted : web.dev · Web Vitals ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Three lab runs yield a mean; no real-visit distribution is available.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Label the result as a lab measurement. Leave the real-use percentile unverified and specify device class.
Read the protocol
Audit a form from start to finish

Error then recovery

In a test environment, does invalid input explain the problem without losing other useful fields? Also check keyboard, language and recovery after server failure.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
After a test-address error, the form also clears the valid subject and message.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Preserve useful input and explain the affected field error. Retest recovery with fictional data.

No duplicate submission

Can double activation or a late response produce two operations? Distinguish displayed success, confirmed receipt and final processing without using real personal data.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The browser shows success after two activations; the number of server-side operations was not observed.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Keep uniqueness unverified. In the test environment, link request identifier to receipt and final processing.

Server-side validation

In the test environment, is an invalid request rejected without browser validation? A client-side message does not guarantee server-side handling.

Documentation consulted : MDN · Constraint validation ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
An invalid test request is rejected by the server without browser validation; no processing record is created.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Retain fictional input, response and server observation. Repeat when validation or processing changes.
Read the protocol
Audit a site’s editorial images

Origin and purpose

Are origin, known rights and modifications documented? Do caption and alternative distinguish documentary photo, logo, diagram and atmosphere illustration?

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
An image is labelled “free” in a folder; author, exact licence and original page are missing.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Do not validate rights from this label alone. Find source and terms, or choose a documented resource.

Actually displayed file

On a small screen, does the chosen file retain dimensions, clarity and meaningful framing? Also check lazy loading and missing resources without artificially enlarging a poor original.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
On mobile, the crop removes the embedded key distinguishing actual data from forecast.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Fix the crop or provide a visible text key. Check the selected file, not only the original.

Data behind a chart

Does a chart have a textual account of its useful information? A generic alternative such as “chart” conveys neither values nor trend.

Documentation consulted : W3C WAI · Images Tutorial ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The tested inventory has no data-bearing chart or diagram, only atmosphere photos.
Declared state
Justified exclusion from scope
Decision and next check
Justify excluding charts. Photo alternatives still require checking; reopen when a chart is added.
Read the protocol
Qualify an open source before using it

Document scope

Are operator, jurisdiction, period, version and exclusions identified? An empty search must retain its query and filters before interpretation.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
A search returns zero results; its query and filters were not retained.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
The scope of absence remains unknown. Repeat a documented search before interpreting the empty result.

Examined independence

Do confirmations rely on distinct documents or the same repeated report? Retain their common origin and narrow the conclusion when corroboration is missing.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Three portals reproduce one dispatch and are presented as three independent confirmations.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Link reproductions to their shared origin. Find an independent record or narrow the conclusion.

Identified transformations

Is each transcription, translation or extraction linked to its original? Read the source passage before judging the derivative’s fidelity.

Documentation consulted : W3C · PROV Overview ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The translation cites its source version and passage; numbers and caveats were checked against the original.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Fidelity of this passage is documented without validating the whole document. Recheck if the source version changes.
Read the protocol
Reconstruct a timeline of public signals

Distinct dates

Does each row separate event, publication, capture and observation, with known precision and time zone? A page update must not become a new event date.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The page was updated in 2024; the timeline dates an explicitly 2021 event to 2024.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Restore event date and retain publication, update and observation separately.

Justified interval

Is the first recovered trace presented as an observation rather than a certain origin? Retain gaps and check the date of each destination when navigating an archive.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The earliest found capture is from 2018; no documented earlier search is available.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Write “trace found in 2018”, without inferring creation in 2018. Document search limits.

Partial capture

Are missing media and links leaving the archive identified? A captured page does not establish that all its resources were preserved.

Documentation consulted : Internet Archive · Wayback Machine General Information ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The record separates the archived page, one missing image and a link opening the live web.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
The partial capture is explicit. Do not date current destination content to the archive date.
Read the protocol
Map actors using public sources

Documented relationship

Does each edge specify relationship type, direction, period, source and status? Graph proximity or a shared address must not replace a relationship document.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Two entities share an address; the graph adds an ownership link without a supporting record.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Remove the unsupported ownership claim and label the shared address. Find evidence specific to the relationship.

Identity before merging

Were nodes matched using compatible identifiers and attributes? Keep namesakes separate and unknown relationships explicit rather than treating them as certain absence.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Nodes A and B share a name; identifiers and periods are missing.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Retain two provisional nodes and an unknown mapping. A missing link does not establish no relationship.

Path and direct link

Is a path through an intermediary distinguished from a direct relationship? Check link type and period before summarising proximity.

Documentation consulted : W3C · Organization Ontology ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The graph retains A → B in 2020 and B → C in 2024; no direct A → C link is asserted.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Path and direct link are distinguished. Check period overlap before interpreting a simultaneous path.
Read the protocol
Verify the context of a public image

Version and context

Was the used version compared with earlier traces, framing and the recovered original caption? Reverse search provides a lead; it does not alone establish date, place or authenticity.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Reverse search finds a thumbnail; the original and first-publication caption remain unavailable.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Keep the trace as a lead without certifying date or place. Seek a fuller version and earlier contexts.

Corroborated clues

Were location and period clues compared with independent sources? Retain contradictions and distinguish present metadata, verified metadata and a visual hypothesis.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The caption names location X; two visible features contradict the map used to support X.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Retain the contradiction and suspend the proposed location. Do not discard conflicting clues to preserve the caption.

Provenance and truth

Is provenance evidence distinguished from the truth of a caption? Its absence alone is also insufficient to declare an image false.

Documentation consulted : C2PA · Content Credentials Explainer 2.2 ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The record separates validated file provenance from an uncorroborated location caption.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
The separation is correct; location remains open. Provenance evidence does not close scene verification.
Read the protocol
Read and cite a public decision

Decision and stage

Do court, number, date and procedural stage identify the exact document? Distinguish request, quoted argument, reasoning and operative decision before summarising.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The summary attributes a party’s quoted request to the judge; the operative part does not adopt it.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Correct attribution and cite request, reasons and operative part separately in the identified document.

Retained scope

Does the wording retain parties, addressed issue, period and document qualifications? Revisit the record if a later decision or correction changes what can be stated.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The initial decision is identified; existence and content of a later decision are unchecked.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Date the search and limit the conclusion to the document read. Check relevant follow-up before claiming current status.

Proposal and decision

For France’s Conseil d’État, are the public rapporteur’s conclusions distinguished from the decision? Do not attribute that proposal to the deciding panel.

Documentation consulted : Conseil d’État · Rôle du rapporteur public ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The file separates the public rapporteur’s proposal and the decision issued; each passage links to its record.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
Retain the distinction in the summary. Recheck attribution when translating or creating another excerpt.
Read the protocol
Assess a public dataset before reuse

Like-for-like comparison

Do compared values use compatible definition, unit, population, area and period? Retain filters, missing values and series breaks rather than inventing continuity.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
Two values are joined by year: one counts people, the other thousands of people in another territory.
Declared state
Observed discrepancy
Decision and next check
Harmonize unit and territory, then check definition and population. Unit conversion alone does not fix scope.

Recoverable extraction

Do the exact distribution, version, licence and transformations permit recalculation? Recheck a series revision before reusing an old chart.

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The calculation retains its result, but resource version, filters and transformations are undocumented.
Declared state
Not checked
Decision and next check
Reproducibility remains unverified. Locate the exact distribution and rebuild steps before reuse.

Record and observations

Is the catalogue update date distinguished from the observation period and version of the resource used?

Documentation consulted : W3C · DCAT 3 ·

View a worked decision

Fictional example: the state applies only to the criterion and scope described.

Fictional observation
The catalog record was updated in 2024; the record retains 2021 observations and resource version V2.
Declared state
Verified within this scope
Decision and next check
The three time dimensions are separated. Do not label the data as 2024 observations; recheck version after revision.
Read the protocol

Using a review

Does a completed review prove compliance?

No. It retains observations within a defined scope. These questions are neither a full audit nor legal, technical or accessibility certification.

How should an inapplicable check be treated?

Explain why it is outside scope: missing resource, unused feature or excluded case.

How should an unchecked item be treated?

Keep that status explicit. An absence of verification cannot establish success.

When should the review be repeated?

After a change to source, version, route, provider or usage that could affect the result. Retain the previous record to compare scopes.

DEEPER READING / PRACTICE

Review conclusions when the evidence changes

An old control remains marked as finished as the source or system has evolved. The review must examine the changes and decide whether the conclusion remains useful.

Updated on .

Priority checks

Compare dates, versions, scope and new observations. Identify the controls to be repeated and the conclusions that depend on the modified elements.

Interpretation pitfalls

The administrative closure of a control does not guarantee its permanent validity. A method change can also make previous results difficult to compare.

Working record to retain

The revision journal retains an old result, change, new judgment and the next deadline. The conclusions taken remain traceable to explain the evolution of the case.

PRACTICAL CASE / WORKED EXAMPLE

A closed result depends on a replaced source

The following case illustrates an approach to defining the need. Situations are pedagogical: they serve to examine the choices and conditions of success, without describing a fulfilled mission or announcing a guaranteed result.

Example context

An old control is marked as finished. The source used has been corrected since then, and the passage on which the conclusion was based has not yet been reviewed.

Suggested approach

Identify the change and dependent conclusions. Repeat the steps affected, compare old and new results, and then update the status with its motif.

Conclusion and next step

The closure is traceable. The dossier retains the historic and distinguishes the still valid elements from the conclusions suspended or replaced.

Questions for deeper practice

When to reopen control?

When a change of source, method or scope affects its result. A new report or contradiction may also justify a targeted review of the relevant steps.

DETAILED WORKSHOP / APPLICATION

Revise a result according to the changes that affect it

  1. 01 / Prepare the necessary information

    Preparing old reports, sources and new observations. Identify changes in version, method, scope or context that may change the conclusion.

  2. 02 / Carry out the approach

    Compare the elements and then repeat the steps affected. Preserve the previous and new judgment. Describe the unrecovered controls and check whether their dependencies remain valid.

  3. 03 / Examine an alternative situation

    If the change does not affect the precise use, explain this maintenance. A review may confirm a conclusion without claiming to have repeated the entire investigation.

  4. 04 / Decide on the next step

    The review is closed when maintenance, correction or suspension are motivated. The next deadline or the useful trigger is linked to the still fragile elements.

  5. 05 / Hand over the verification records

    Transmit history, change and decision. The file remains understandable when the evidence changes and several people intervene at different dates.

ANNOTATED WORKING DOCUMENT / REVIEW GRID

History of maintenance, correction and suspension

The history retains the previous result, change, steps repeated and new assessment. It explains which conclusions still stand and which the new evidence no longer supports.

On a small screen, scroll the grid horizontally to read all three columns.

Example situations to assess
ObservationSupported interpretationNext step
The change does not affect the precise use.The conclusion can stand following an explained, targeted review.Identify the scope of control and the next trigger.
A corrected source changes the main proof.The result must be reviewed before new use.Take the steps involved and compare the conclusions.
The statute remains closed despite a new contradiction.The administrative history no longer reflects the documentary situation.Close the point concerned and qualify the limit.

Reviewing the working document

The final verification must find the reason for each evolution. A review can confirm a result without doing anything again, but it must announce the dependencies examined and the elements left out of control.

REPORTING / EXAMPLE WORDING

Presentation of results: Revise the conclusions when evidence changes

Point to clarify

A closed conclusion may require a review when evidence changes.

Before handing over

Relate each maintenance or suspension to the change and verified dependencies.

Example of a qualified conclusion

The affected steps have been repeated and the new assessment is justified. Retained elements that were not re-examined remain identified in the history.